Live Chat & Podcast at 1:00PM Eastern on Sunday!
There's no such thing as a stupid question, but they're the easiest to answer.
JoinTour
Login
Search
Civilized Debate
Tag Cloud
access acer asus bios bsod computer crash desktop driver drivers error ethernet excel freeze gaming hard drive hardware hdmi internet laptop malware memory modem monitor motherboard network printer problem ram registry router security slow software sound toshiba trojan ubuntu 11.10 uninstall usb video virus vista wifi windows windows 7 windows 7 32 bit windows 7 64 bit windows xp wireless
Search
Search for:
Tech Support Guy Forums > Community > Controversial Topics > Civilized Debate >
Are technological dangers a process of Natural Selection?

View Poll Results: Are technological dangers a process of Natural Selection?
Man is an animal . 9 42.86%
Man's intellect is one aspect that distinguishes him from the rest of the animal kingdom. 12 57.14%
Man's intellect is now a consideration beyond the processes of natural selection 6 28.57%
Stupidity is equal to ignorance 4 19.05%
I am not an animal. 4 19.05%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 21. You may not vote on this poll

 
Thread Tools
iltos's Avatar
iltos has a Photo Album
Distinguished Member with 18,316 posts.
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Sierra Madre, CA
Experience: Beginner
18-Jul-2007, 09:06 PM #46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chicon
Hi BF,

I still bear in mind that lady gorilla using a giant leave as a napkin.

Technology, an evolutionary force : I'm not sure but I prefer Technology, the resulting force of an evolved species.
but that brings us back to the benefit of intellect as a selected adaptation....that certainly qualifies as an evolutionary force....could it be argued that its benefit is to give evolution direction? (i'd imagine that intelligent design people would love that)

in that case, technology would just be one possible direction...maybe not even the best....

every adaptation carries with it the risk of failure
__________________
"When we face the empire, we face ourselves...
to survive, it is imperative that we cease to lie to ourselves about our condition."
Stoner's Avatar
Account Disabled with 47,328 posts.
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Dayton,Oh
18-Jul-2007, 09:14 PM #47
Quote:
Originally Posted by BanditFlyer
But it's basically the same thing, isn't it? When man first started using tools, I imagine they were stone tools, picked up off the ground, like a chimp does with a stick. Then man discovered they'd be more usefull if he shaped them or chipped them. (For that matter, perhaps even chimps alter the sticks they use in some way.)

Probably didn't take long to start looking for the best place to find the most usefull rocks, which would have eventually led to mining technology, the bronze age, etc. Take that process to it's natural end and we end up synthesising elements that don't(or can't) exist in nature, like the heaviest ones on the Periodic table.

So it looks like nothing more than a matter of degree.

This reminds me of that old discussion we had about Stanley Kubrik's 2001, A Space Oddysey.

I think that better chronicles the development of man's intellect.
The chimp, and what appears to be the rest of the animal kingdom, is stuck implementing what is at hand while man invents, from his mind, that which we call technology.
Evolution appears to have favored man in this regard and man is now diverted from the 'rules' of natural selection that shaped us. We now influence our own 'shape' as we
contemplate what is of benefit.

Last edited by Stoner; 18-Jul-2007 at 09:15 PM.. Reason: clarity
iltos's Avatar
iltos has a Photo Album
Distinguished Member with 18,316 posts.
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Sierra Madre, CA
Experience: Beginner
18-Jul-2007, 09:37 PM #48
Quote:
Originally Posted by BanditFlyer
I'm guessing back then, a picture painted far fewer words than it does today.
was going back over this thread...missed this

my first thought was just to agree....because language is so much more developed, and so many of us now share a common world view....or at least different ones that have a common mantle beneath them

but then i step back in time 50,000 years and i look at that picture of an elk...and i see a REPRESENTATION of something, something that is an elk, but is not an elk.... and the drawing is something that didn't even exist 2 minutes ago, and i am faced with the experience of its meaning, and the experience of the person who put it up on that wall, and the experiences of meaning that it has for others.

and suddenly i am among the first animals on this planet to have reached through the smoke of instinctual behavior and to be burned by the fire of intellect.

maybe that's the point where words (.....yeah, well....sounds, at least) started to take on worldview kinds of importance.
__________________
"When we face the empire, we face ourselves...
to survive, it is imperative that we cease to lie to ourselves about our condition."

Last edited by iltos; 18-Jul-2007 at 09:44 PM..
valis's Avatar
Computer Specs
Moderator with 48,702 posts.
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: as above
Experience: so below
18-Jul-2007, 11:25 PM #49
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stoner
I think that better chronicles the development of man's intellect.
The chimp, and what appears to be the rest of the animal kingdom, is stuck implementing what is at hand while man invents, from his mind, that which we call technology.
Evolution appears to have favored man in this regard and man is now diverted from the 'rules' of natural selection that shaped us. We now influence our own 'shape' as we
contemplate what is of benefit.
at some point in time, we were all in trees. Some of us still are, for that matter. Then some of us came down from trees onto the savannah. Well, that grass was rather high, and that sort of forced us to raise our head now and again to make sure nothing was sneaking up on us. Pretty soon, we were more or less fully bipedal. That freed our hands to begin tool manipulation, which began a spiral; one tool invented, brain sees another implementation for said tool if you just add this widget here, and now you've got a two function tool, that requires a bit more oomph upstairs to carry out. Brain literally explodes over a very short period of time, resulting in two major factors:

1. Tool implementaion and complexity grew very, very rapidly.

2. The larger cranial size meant that birth became a rather difficult engineering process, akin to passing a bowling ball through a lightly greased straw.

Result? Lots of deaths, both mom and baby. Solution? Shorten the gestation period to get the baby out earlier. Deleterious effects? We now have a baby who is utterly and completely unable to care for themself, whereas a thousand or hundred thousand generations before, they came out ready to go. So we now have outer-womb raising, akin to the marsupials, only without the snot-filled pouch.

Upside, that gave us even more room in the cranium. Result?

Wheel of Fortune. Seriously. What does Vanna put on her resume? Smiles, claps, touches letters.
__________________
Microsoft M.V.P. - Windows IT Professional | M.C.S.A. | M.C.P. - MS Server 2k3 | blog | rate me

"Ask Bill why the string in function 9 is terminated by a dollar sign. Ask him, because he can't answer. Only I know that". - Gary Kildall
Gabriel's Avatar
Gabriel has a Photo Album
Computer Specs
Account Closed with 17,511 posts.
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Home sweet home
Experience: Can Follow Directions
18-Jul-2007, 11:41 PM #50
But is it merely intellect of the mind that does all this?
As Valis points out, a lot of body modification has gone on too, perhaps.
Also, if we are no longer animal, then there is more than mere adaptation of genes....what I am saying is if we have changed into higher beings from a lower state of being, don't we perhaps now have spirit, or soul that truely has purpose and possibility of growth?
BanditFlyer's Avatar
Distinguished Member with 12,582 posts.
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: BOT бaHДиT
Experience: (50-6) 44ko, one earlobe
18-Jul-2007, 11:47 PM #51
Quote:
Originally Posted by valis
Upside, that gave us even more room in the cranium. Result?

Wheel of Fortune. Seriously. What does Vanna put on her resume? Smiles, claps, touches letters.
Maybe this is why celebrities need "agents".
Quote:
Originally Posted by iltos
... and suddenly i am among the first animals on this planet to have reached through the smoke of instinctual behavior and to be burned by the fire of intellect.

maybe that's the point where words (.....yeah, well....sounds, at least) started to take on worldview kinds of importance.
And then ... there was Vanna White. Thank God we didn't let it go to waste, eh?
BanditFlyer's Avatar
Distinguished Member with 12,582 posts.
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: BOT бaHДиT
Experience: (50-6) 44ko, one earlobe
18-Jul-2007, 11:49 PM #52
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabriel
But is it merely intellect of the mind that does all this?
As Valis points out, a lot of body modification has gone on too, perhaps.
Also, if we are no longer animal, then there is more than mere adaptation of genes....what I am saying is if we have changed into higher beings from a lower state of being, don't we perhaps now have spirit, or soul that truely has purpose and possibility of growth?
Or maybe animals have souls as well? They evolved too.
Gabriel's Avatar
Gabriel has a Photo Album
Computer Specs
Account Closed with 17,511 posts.
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Home sweet home
Experience: Can Follow Directions
18-Jul-2007, 11:50 PM #53
Quote:
Originally Posted by BanditFlyer
Or maybe animals have souls as well? They evolved too.
Maybe...
pyritechips's Avatar
pyritechips has a Photo Album
Computer Specs
Community Moderator with 24,368 posts.
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
18-Jul-2007, 11:57 PM #54
Souls? I deny such an entity. Define a soul. Show me one. Prove that a human (God's protegé) has a soul and any other animal does not.

I think what has happened here is that the "soul" of Biblical fame has come to represent the infusion of God into his physical incarnation on Earth. It is a wonderful sentiment, if you believe in God. The believe of a superior being has always been an obsticale in the pursuit of knowledge.
__________________
"Irony is more humane than its sneering cousin, sarcasm, which is intended to demolish and ridicule." - Richard Handler.
"Respect is earned; it is not a birthright." - Me
"And what is good, Phaedrus, And what is not good - Need we ask anyone to tell us these things?" - Plato
Gabriel's Avatar
Gabriel has a Photo Album
Computer Specs
Account Closed with 17,511 posts.
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Home sweet home
Experience: Can Follow Directions
19-Jul-2007, 12:00 AM #55
I am looking at it from the perspective of evolving from an animal into a human.....territory unreached and such...... It isn't meant to be an argument itself...just an angle.
And who says I'm using it in your frame of reference anyway?
Gabriel's Avatar
Gabriel has a Photo Album
Computer Specs
Account Closed with 17,511 posts.
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Home sweet home
Experience: Can Follow Directions
19-Jul-2007, 12:02 AM #56
Oh, and I certainly never said animals don't have souls.....
BanditFlyer's Avatar
Distinguished Member with 12,582 posts.
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: BOT бaHДиT
Experience: (50-6) 44ko, one earlobe
19-Jul-2007, 12:06 AM #57
Quote:
Originally Posted by pyritechips
Souls? I deny such an entity. Define a soul. Show me one. Prove that a human (God's protegé) has a soul and any other animal does not.

I think what has happened here is that the "soul" of Biblical fame has come to represent the infusion of God into his physical incarnation on Earth. It is a wonderful sentiment, if you believe in God. The believe of a superior being has always been an obsticale in the pursuit of knowledge.
May you mistake your Preparation H for Pepsodent.

Please, please, please take this post from here and move it to one of the "religion versus pseudo-science" threads.

I'll be back here in a week or so and I don't want to see some new member like imrippinit telling you to prove the non-existence of a soul.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabriel
And who says I'm using it in your frame of reference anyway?
Yeah, what she said!
__________________
Don't taze me, Bro!


(there's got to be a dance version of that somewhere - remember the old song "Don't hurt me"?)
iltos's Avatar
iltos has a Photo Album
Distinguished Member with 18,316 posts.
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Sierra Madre, CA
Experience: Beginner
19-Jul-2007, 02:14 AM #58
Quote:
Originally Posted by valis
Well, that grass was rather high, and that sort of forced us to raise our head now and again to make sure nothing was sneaking up on us. Pretty soon, we were more or less fully bipedal. That freed our hands to begin tool manipulation, which began a spiral; one tool invented, brain sees another implementation for said tool if you just add this widget here, and now you've got a two function tool, that requires a bit more oomph upstairs to carry out. Brain literally explodes over a very short period of time, resulting in two major factors:

1. Tool implementaion and complexity grew very, very rapidly.

2. The larger cranial size meant that birth became a rather difficult engineering process, akin to passing a bowling ball through a lightly greased straw.

Result? Lots of deaths, both mom and baby. Solution? Shorten the gestation period to get the baby out earlier. Deleterious effects? We now have a baby who is utterly and completely unable to care for themself, whereas a thousand or hundred thousand generations before, they came out ready to go. So we now have outer-womb raising, akin to the marsupials, only without the snot-filled pouch.

Upside, that gave us even more room in the cranium.
nice train of thought ...gives caves (for protection -slash- nurseries for newborns) and all the rest some elegant place in the progression

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gabriel
As Valis points out, a lot of body modification has gone on too, perhaps.
....what I am saying is if we have changed into higher beings from a lower state of being, don't we perhaps now have spirit, or soul that truely has purpose and possibility of growth?
i can't make that leap just yet....suffice it to say that intellect, having exploded on the scene, created possibilities limited only by our ability to manifest the convergence of observation and imagination (the elk on the wall), that intellect is responsible for both technology and yoga, and that both are developments in the organization of self

is that a world view that is different from the hawk, the platypus, or the elephant?

certainly

does it define the spritual nature of man?

i'll leave that up to you

but, again, and imo, if intelligent design afficinados pursued these same kinds of discussions, they might find something very appealing in the theory of evolution.
__________________
"When we face the empire, we face ourselves...
to survive, it is imperative that we cease to lie to ourselves about our condition."
LuckyStrike's Avatar
Senior Member with 2,145 posts.
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Experience: Intermediate
19-Jul-2007, 02:52 AM #59
I wonder. Does any animal feel regret after killing another animal?

Quote:
I am not an animal! I am a human being!

Elephant Man
lotuseclat79's Avatar
Distinguished Member with 21,345 posts.
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: -71.45091, 42.27841
19-Jul-2007, 08:07 AM #60
Quote:
Originally Posted by valis
...

Wheel of Fortune. Seriously. What does Vanna put on her resume? Smiles, claps, touches letters.
Hi valis,

Vanna's resume: Wheel of Fortune game show hostess with the mostess! Special talent in turning around lettered answers. Seeks advice column in local, regional or nationally syndicated newspaper.

-- Tom
 

THIS THREAD HAS EXPIRED.
Are you having the same problem? We have volunteers ready to answer your question, but first you'll have to join for free. Need help getting started? Check out our Welcome Guide.

Search Tech Support Guy

Find the solution to your
computer problem!




Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
WELCOME TO TECH SUPPORT GUY! Are you looking for the solution to your computer problem? Join our site today to ask your question -- for free! Our site is run completely by volunteers who want to help you solve your computer problems. See our Welcome Guide to get started.
Thread Tools



Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter TechGuy.tv TechGuy.tv Mobile TSG Mobile
You Are Using:
Server ID
Advertisements do not imply our endorsement of that product or service.
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:17 PM.
Copyright © 1996 - 2011 TechGuy, Inc. All rights reserved.

Powered by Cermak Technologies, Inc.